So, You Want to Be a People Manager
Workplace culture assessment data tells us that most people who are tapped to become people managers earned that opportunity by excelling as individual contributors — not by exhibiting the fundamental skills for every people manager. Strong individual performance, visible drive, and perceived leadership potential naturally draw the attention of leaders building succession pipelines. The assumption is understandable — if you’re great at the work, you’ll be great at leading the people who do it.
That assumption is also where many management careers go off track.
Being offered a management role is flattering. It signals trust, raises visibility, and often comes with increased influence. But before saying yes, both you and your manager should be clear-eyed about what success actually requires. The capabilities that made you valuable as an individual contributor are not the same ones that will make you effective as a people leader.
As a people manager, your job shifts from doing the work to enabling the work of others. Results come less from your personal execution and more from how well you:
Some high performers struggle because they continue to lead the way they worked — jumping in too fast, solving instead of coaching, or avoiding tough conversations in order to stay liked. Others underestimate the emotional labor of management: navigating conflict, motivating uneven performers, and balancing business demands with human realities.
If you want to be a people manager, ask yourself a few hard questions.
- Are you willing to let go of being the go-to expert?
- Can you give candid feedback even when it’s uncomfortable?
- Do you get energy from developing others, not just from achieving your own wins?
Management is not a promotion in the traditional sense — it’s a career pivot. When that pivot is made deliberately, with the right expectations and skill development, it can be deeply rewarding. When it’s made casually, it often becomes frustrating for everyone involved.
Wanting the role is a good start. Understanding what it truly demands to be a successful people manager is what determines whether you’ll succeed.
Fundamental Skills for Every People Manager
Leading others comes with a new set of responsibilities. If you manage people, there are a few core skills — validated through our people manager assessment center — that you must intentionally develop and consistently apply.
- The Ability to Create Team Clarity
Strong people managers begin with clarity, not motivation. Before asking for commitment or performance, they ensure that everyone understands why the team exists, what success looks like, and how each person contributes. The most effective way to do this is by establishing a clear team charter that creates line of sight between daily work and meaningful outcomes.
Our organizational alignment research shows just how powerful this is: team clarity accounts for 31 percent of the performance gap between high- and low-performing teams. You know you have sufficient team clarity when there is shared commitment and alignment — not vague agreement — on the fundamentals:
- The Ability to Communicate with Understanding and Purpose
This may be the most fundamental leadership capability of all. Purposeful communication improves decision-making, builds trust, enables change, and drives engagement by helping employees understand not just what is happening, but why it matters. Effective people managers do not talk more — they communicate better.
They are clear in what they say, intentional in how they say it, and thoughtful about how it will be received. They strip out noise, eliminate ambiguity, and shape messages around what matters most to their audience. Just as important, they listen to understand, not to respond. Listening is not passive; it is an active effort to grasp context, intent, and underlying concerns.
Strong communication is never a one-way transmission. It requires curiosity, patience, and the discipline to ask clarifying questions before forming conclusions or making decisions. Managers who communicate well create space for dialogue, surface issues early, and prevent misunderstandings from turning into larger problems.
When communication is sloppy or inconsistent, even well-intended leaders generate confusion, skepticism, and unnecessary friction. When it is deliberate and grounded in understanding, people managers earn credibility — and teams move forward with confidence and alignment.
- The Ability to be Self-Aware
Most people can describe the surface elements of who they are — their role, experience, and accomplishments. That’s not what matters most in leadership. What separates effective people managers from the rest is insight into their inner layers: motives, blind spots, triggers, and impact.
Self-awareness is a foundational leadership capability because it shapes every interaction you have. It influences how you make decisions, how you respond under pressure, and how others experience working with you. The question is not whether you have strengths — it’s whether you understand them well enough to use them deliberately. More importantly, are you clear-eyed about your weaknesses, or do they quietly manage you instead?
Strong leaders seek objective feedback. They know how they are perceived, not just how they intend to show up. They also ask a harder question: is that perception aligned with who I want to be as a leader? When there is a gap, they take responsibility for closing it rather than rationalizing it away.
This is where your personal leadership brand is formed — not through aspiration, but through consistent leadership behavior over time. If the way you are currently experienced does not support your leadership goals, improvement is possible. It requires honest reflection, credible feedback, and the willingness to change habits that may have worked earlier in your career but now limit your effectiveness.
Leaders who understand themselves lead with greater intention, credibility, and impact.
- The Ability to Ethically Persuade and Influence
No leader accomplishes meaningful goals alone. Results at scale require the ability to align people, earn commitment, and mobilize effort — not through authority, but through influence. People managers must be able to persuade others to invest energy in a direction they genuinely believe is worth pursuing.
Effective influence starts with understanding. Strong leaders have a practical awareness of what matters to different individuals and groups — their priorities, pressures, risks, and motivations. Without that insight, persuasion becomes generic and ineffective. With it, leaders can frame ideas in ways that resonate and address real concerns rather than abstract objectives.
Influence is not about pushing harder or selling louder. It is about guiding people toward a shared purpose and helping them see how their contributions matter. When leaders connect the work to outcomes people care about, commitment follows. When they ignore those realities, compliance replaces engagement — and performance suffers.
The ability to persuade and influence is the mechanism by which vision turns into action and strategy turns into results. Leaders who master this skill consistently inspire higher effort, stronger alignment, and sustained momentum.
- The Ability to Learn from Experience and Apply the Lessons
Effective leaders treat experience as a teacher, not a scorecard. They seek input from others, reflect on what worked and what didn’t, and adjust their approach accordingly. Mistakes are inevitable. What differentiates strong people managers is their ability to extract insight from those moments and apply it the next time.
This requires intellectual humility and adaptability. Are you willing to challenge your own assumptions? Can you change course when evidence suggests a better path? Leaders who cling to outdated views in order to protect their ego eventually stall their teams and themselves.
The best managers are energized by learning. They are curious problem solvers who look for patterns, test ideas, and refine how they lead over time. Continuous learning is not a side activity; it is how they stay effective in changing conditions.
Experience alone does not create better leaders. Experience examined, understood, and intentionally applied does. People managers who learn this lesson early build resilience, credibility, and long-term leadership effectiveness.
The Bottom Line
Managing a team is a meaningful challenge — and one that should be taken on deliberately. Appreciation and enthusiasm are not enough. Success as a people manager depends on having access to the right management training and development experiences to build the fundamental skills the role demands. The shift is real and often uncomfortable: your results are no longer defined by what you personally deliver, but by what others achieve through you. The most important question to answer honestly is whether you are ready to have your success depend on the success of others.
To learn more about fundamental skills for every people manager, download 5 Management Misperceptions that Slip Up Too Many New Managers
Tristam Brown is an executive business consultant and organizational development expert with more than three decades of experience helping organizations accelerate performance, build high-impact teams, and turn strategy into execution. As CEO of LSA Global, he works with leaders to get and stay aligned™ through research-backed strategy, culture, and talent solutions that produce measurable, business-critical results. See full bio.
0
