5 Decision Making Tips for New Managers

5 Decision Making Tips for New Managers
Facebook Twitter Email LinkedIn

Making the Right Decision
When you become a new manager, it can be tempting to make some immediate and bold decisions to prove your worth.  But we know from decades of decision making tips for new managers that new supervisors are at high risk of misjudging strategies, situations, processes, people, and politics if they make decisions too quickly.  The best new leaders resist the urge to act quickly and focus on listening, observing, and learning for at least the first 30-60 days.

Sure, there may be simple choices to be made or a crisis that needs to be solved immediately, but many decisions for new leaders can be complex, involve multiple stakeholders, have far-reaching implications, and seldom can you predict which of several options will be the best in the end.

5 Decision Making Tips for New Managers
Once you know that you have a decision to make, here are some decision making tips for new managers from a recent strategic decision making training workshop that can help :

  1. Agree Upon the Levels of Importance, Urgency, and Risk
    Before gathering information and allocating resources, the most effective leaders agree upon the levels of importance, urgency, and risk.

    They understand the impact of the decision upon their key stakeholders; they know how high a priority it is in the grand scheme of things; they identify the key risks; and they define the required time parameters.

  2. Define Your Decision Making Criteria
    Once the big picture is clear, it is time to identify and prioritize all of the different factors that you and your team must take into account. Your decision making criteria should be measurable and relevant to your strategy, culture, team and the scope of the problem you are trying to solve.

    Typical decision making criteria include factors such as ability to implement, financial, scalability, time, quality, flexibility, risk, culture and people implications, customer impact, competition, and change readiness.

  3. Gather Relevant Information
    Once your decision making criteria is clear, it the responsibility of new managers to ensure that the information required to make an informed, timely, and effective decision is gathered. Use whatever means you have at your disposal—knowledgeable colleagues, relevant reports, past experience, and future trends.

    Understand that you are unlikely to be able to pull together all the data that would highlight a single path to take.  Focus on narrowing the choices by eliminating some that are clearly wrong and make informed strategic, cultural and people assumptions to overcome the common barrier of unclear information.

    Then document the most important information you are missing so you know where you stand.

  4. Identify Viable Alternatives and Consequences
    Help your team to identify at least three or four realistic alternatives. For each alternative identify the pros, the cons, the uncertainties and the potential consequences.  Generating alternatives may sound like it will slow you down, but expanding your choices forces your team to innovate and look at the problem from different perspectives.

    Of all the decision making tips for new managers, presenting viable alternatives and consequences seems to ease the pain and difficulty of choosing the best path.

  5. Be Decisive
    Once you’ve evaluated the viable options, the next step is to make your decision. Yes, take some time to consider all options.  But then don’t postpone your decision too long.

    Remember, there is rarely a “perfect” answer for complex decisions. You need to make the best decisions with the information available and begin to move in the chosen direction.

    Just make sure you have a process in place to track progress and adjust as needed.

The Bottom Line
As a new manager, you have a lot invested in you and your team making the best decisions.  You want your team to trust your leadership from the get-go.  You can certainly ask for and consider their input. In the end, however, the decision is up to you.  Follow the field-tested decision making tips for new managers.

To learn more about how to create the environment for good decision making, download 29 Ways to Build and Maintain Trust as a Leader

Evaluate your Performance


Download key published insights and tools from industry experts highlighting best practices in the areas of talent, strategy and culture.


Health Checks

Want to know how you stack up against leading organizations?  Receive a complimentary benchmarking analysis courtesy of an LSA Expert.



Get up to speed on timely solutions critical to your business. Published by LSA Experts based upon client feedback and key industry trends.



First we identify the key metrics you want to improve. Then we assemble a dedicated team of elite experts who have successfully solved similar problems with similar clients.



Stay up to do date with the latest information on how we help high growth companies align their culture and talent with strategy.


Client Case Studies

Real world consulting and training approaches from LSA projects, providing insights on how your company can outperform the competition.